Da Mario Pizzeria in Rutderford

Da Mario Pizzeria in Rutderford
4.1
50reviews
View phone 12019355817

25 Park Ave, Rutderford, NJ 07070-1711, Rutderford

Overview

Cuisine

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Questions and answers

View all q&a

Do they accept credit cards

Yes they do and there food is great

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Da Mario Pizzeria
RG

Raviv Greenberg

google
11.21.2024
5/5

Great food at decent prices, not just pizza.

Da Mario Pizzeria
AC

Alex Cat3

google
11.20.2018
4/5

As the other reviews say, very good pizza but spotty delivery.

Da Mario Pizzeria
SD

Steven Deollas

google
10.18.2018
5/5

Good quick eats , same friendly staff , pizza is good daily specials , student discounts , enjoy !

Da Mario Pizzeria
MO

Mister Owl

google
09.09.2018
3/5

Cooks are great, staff is friendly. The pizza has the best crust in town, in my opinion. The service inside is great, but don't order delivery. Even on a Monday it takes longer than an hour. One time, the cheese came off my pizza before I received it, because the driver was hasty. I love going there but they need new drivers, and better delivery times.

Da Mario Pizzeria
NR

Natalie Reynas

google
07.26.2018
5/5

I Love There Pizza & Penne Alla Vodka Pasta Is Great 👍🏻

Da Mario Pizzeria
RT

Robby T

google
07.17.2018
4/5

Really good for an inexpensive lunch with a ton of options. Good location. Friendly service. Great for kids.

Da Mario Pizzeria
DM

Dennis McKeon

google
06.05.2018
5/5

I go here often. I've never been disappointed. Tina the waitress is great. More importantly, the food is great. The ambieance....well you have table service and a flat screen TV. Not bad.

Da Mario Pizzeria

Xero

google
05.18.2018
1/5

This is second time they delivered to wrong place and got a cold pizza.Not exactly cold but you know what I mean....pizza dough was wet because of fresh cut tomato popping. Not so happy. I wanted to hear "sorry" instead of "delivery guy is coming, Sweaty" before receptionist hung up my phone call I even didn't finish speaking.

Da Mario Pizzeria
OS

Ozgur S

google
05.07.2018
1/5

I was going to this place almost everyday spending decent amount money and tip waitresses all the time.. later I decided not to go there anymore because I realized that owner started to charge me an extra for little things i asked for making more money and also the service is very slow and everything takes long time so I understood this place never deserve a good customer like me.. I should never go to this place to waste my time and money again,Thats how he deserve.

Da Mario Pizzeria
JB

Jeremy Back

google
04.10.2018
5/5

Best pizza in Rutherford, my wife and I have tried them all

Da Mario Pizzeria
CB

Cynthia Blauvelt

google
04.04.2018
1/5

PIZZA ICE COLD AND DISGUSTING LIKE EATING OLD CARDBOARD PIZZA, AND THEY ARE ONLY 1/8 OF A MILE AWAY TO DELIVER. NEVER AGAIN

Da Mario Pizzeria
eR

eddie Rom

google
02.08.2018
5/5

Been there 4 times and the food is great and affortable... Love it.

Da Mario Pizzeria
ms

mini shah

google
02.02.2018
5/5

Awesome food and service

Da Mario Pizzeria
ag

antoni grebowiec

google
01.24.2018
5/5

they improved on their food tastes better and the little mistakes they made in the past are all gone good job

Da Mario Pizzeria
AA

Alexa Avecillas

google
11.27.2017
4/5

I haven't received bad service from them but I know that they serve the food well and it is delicious. I order the chicken saltimboca (I think that's how its spelled lol) many times, its my favorite dish! Nice spaghetti with spinach and cooked chicken. I even had them deliver dinner to the house (it was a whole order of 5 meals in total) and everything was in the bags. No complaint from me!

Da Mario Pizzeria
MS

Mr. Sinch

google
11.22.2017
5/5

Real cozy. Great service.

Da Mario Pizzeria
SS

S S

google
10.09.2017
4/5

Always nice guys delivering pizza. Also this pizza is the best one around East Rutherford/Rutherford area that I’ve tasted.

Da Mario Pizzeria
P4

ProRoller 420

google
09.15.2017
5/5

ProRoller signing in!Hello Rutherford if you ladys & gentlemen enjoy good quality pizza here is you best option. Personaly i love the pizza and great food they make here. Go inside sit down if you want and enjoy with your family you will have a great and pleasant time. Ps go enjoy that amazing pizza

Da Mario Pizzeria
GG

Glenn Gargiulo

google
09.09.2017
4/5

Food is great here but definitely eat there or pick it up. For some reason it isn't as good when it gets delivered.

Da Mario Pizzeria
TS

Takhia Shankle

google
09.03.2017
1/5

OMG!! I ordered spaghetti and meatballs and it was disgusting!! It tasted as if a can of tomato sauce was just poured onto spaghetti noodles and heated up, no taste at all. The meatballs were definitely not real beef and they were tasteless. I assumed for the price of a dinner spaghetti I would at least get onions, peppers, mushrooms and real beef. My garlic bread had no garlic. I was really displeased!

Da Mario Pizzeria
MG

Michael Gerbasio

google
08.13.2017
5/5

My family has ordered from DaMario's every Friday for the past 8 years. The food is consistently delicious and service is great. My kids are on a first name basis with Marco the pizza guy, as well as just about everyone else in there. Reasonably priced and always on point

Da Mario Pizzeria
JH

John Hedrick

google
07.14.2017
4/5

Excellent food, staff, and service.

Da Mario Pizzeria
AR

Ashley Rose Vega

google
07.08.2017
5/5

I've been coming here since I'm a kid, always friendly service, and I think I've tried every single pizza. It's awesome!

Da Mario Pizzeria
LQ

Louann Quevedo

google
06.23.2017
4/5

Just ordered a pizza...and it was absolutely the worst pizza I ever had....I wonder if the cheese was bad...it tasted sour. The crust was horrible. I wasted 15.00. Had to throw it out...wish I could get my money back!

Da Mario Pizzeria
HB

Hunter Bishop

google
05.12.2017
3/5

Excellent staff, pizza is good; unfortunately the platters leave much to be desired.

Da Mario Pizzeria
CP

Carlos Perez

google
04.09.2017
5/5

Had A Cold Sub, delicious and a great price

Da Mario Pizzeria
EH

Eleanor Higham

google
03.26.2017
5/5

Awsome pizza (New York style), I come from NY and have had some great pizza. Also the dinners, salads, heroes and soups are delicious. And their prices and specials are great!

Da Mario Pizzeria
JG

Jack Garber

google
03.14.2017
4/5

Friendly community pizza place. I especially found it thoughtful that they cater to local high school students with a special low price menu. Their antipasto salad is tops. Pizzas are prepared perfectly.

Da Mario Pizzeria
CH

Chuck Heber

google
03.01.2017
3/5

Good daily specials

Da Mario Pizzeria
TB

Tim Barbosa

google
02.06.2017
5/5

A good place to eat.

Da Mario Pizzeria
MN

Mark Naideck

google
01.25.2017
5/5

The best bang for the buck in Rutherford. Really good, homemade Italian food, nice people and great prices! The veal dishes are incredible...I don't know how they do it for the price they charge !

Da Mario Pizzeria
TC

Terry Curtis

google
01.04.2017
5/5

Took a little longer than expected for it to be made, but it was well worth the wait. Excellent flavor and great crust. I travel a lot, but this one goes on my list of favorites.

Da Mario Pizzeria

Joe

google
10.13.2016
5/5

Been coming here since high school. Great staff and great food.

Da Mario Pizzeria
AE

Amine Elm

google
09.06.2016
5/5

Classic italian

Da Mario Pizzeria
RS

Robert Stuart

google
08.26.2016
3/5

Cheap food

Da Mario Pizzeria
LH

Layla Hennessy

google
08.08.2016
4/5

Pizza is ok the price is great. Staff is friendly. Would recommend for a quick bite.

Da Mario Pizzeria
CG

Cynthia Geraldino

google
07.10.2016
1/5

Food was okay until one day when I ordered food and it tasted sour (sort of like raid roach spray). They like to charge extra for pretty much everything and the lady who answers the phone is disgusting. I stopped ordering from here because her attitude and the food sucks.

Da Mario Pizzeria
HC

Hilda C.

google
06.23.2016
5/5

The best pizza in town

Da Mario Pizzeria
JM

Joseph Mcallister

google
06.07.2016
4/5

A Good Friday night pizza if you do the switch from park tavern but why would you???

Da Mario Pizzeria
ad

anne d

google
06.07.2016
5/5

Great food and good service

Da Mario Pizzeria
BL

Beth Lozada

google
05.27.2016
5/5

Food is fresh and pizza is delicious. I always go here at least once a week.

Da Mario Pizzeria
JR

Joseph Remuszka

google
05.22.2016
4/5

They have gotten much better ...the catered meat balls are off the chain good

Da Mario Pizzeria
GD

Gober Deleon

google
05.20.2016
5/5

Really good food, and service, excellent nice and clean

Da Mario Pizzeria
CE

Colleen Elizabeth

google
05.04.2016
5/5

Best Italian food in Bergen County!!!...they cater to all ages... Adult dining even BYOB but its also a place teens can go to eat lunch in the afternoon and feel wanted...

Da Mario Pizzeria
JT

Janilda Tejada

google
05.04.2016
4/5

Great pizza

Da Mario Pizzeria
ZB

Zane Barrow

google
05.04.2016
4/5

The food is cheap and surprisingly decent quality. You expect the place to be kinda trashy from the atmosphere, but it's absolutely not bad.

Da Mario Pizzeria
MM

Michael Mangual

google
04.11.2016
5/5

Good pizza, best in the area in my opinion. Cheap and good. My personal favorite is the pizza parmigiana chicken.

Da Mario Pizzeria
SP

Shar P

google
02.23.2016
2/5

Wonderful Counter Service, Food Horrible

Da Mario Pizzeria
JL

Jennifer Lynn

google
01.25.2016
5/5

Their food is sooo good!!! The pizza, chicken nuggets, french fries, salads, Sicilian pizza all sooo good.

Da Mario Pizzeria
JJ

J. Jasmine Lee

google
01.10.2016
5/5

Great food. I like the Margherita pizza pie with extra basil. The service is great, although delivery can be inconsistent so we generally pick up now. (We've had our pizza delivered with ALL the cheese in one corner of the box. They were courteous and reasonable when I called to complain. I believe they sent us a new one and took the first attempt back.)

Da Mario Pizzeria in Rutderford

25 Park Ave, Rutderford, NJ 07070-1711, Rutderford

4.1
50

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12019355817

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!